What is Donald Schon’s Theory of Reflective Practice?

Probably one of the most influential theories within the domains of education, healthcare, and management, among others, is the theory of reflective practice by Donald Schon. First published in his seminal works “The Reflective Practitioner” (1983) and “Educating the Reflective Practitioner” (1987), Schön’s work has restructured how professionals conceive their practice and how they go about learning from experience. At the very heart of Schön’s theory lies reflection in action; that is, professionals are supposed to learn, not just to reflect after the fact but amidst action. Indeed, this approach to learning and professional development has been a central cornerstone of the training and education of practitioners across many fields.Schön defines reflection as the ability of professionals to examine their actions and decisions to understand and practice with effectiveness better. The theorist is based on two major types of reflection;

Reflection-in-Action: This is taken to be the capacity of reflection and adaptation in the midst of action. The practical example is when a teacher gets to realize, in the middle of some instruction, that some concept being taught is not getting through to the learners and will change the tact right on the spot. This is a type of reflection that is immediate and happens in real-time, thus allowing for the professional dynamism in response to the thrown challenge.

Reflection-on-Action: This type of reflection takes place after the event, where the professional reviews and analyses his performance to understand what happened and why. For example, after an encounter with a patient where proper or better ways of handling the situation could have been considered, a health professional may reflect on what he did right or what he could have done better. The reflection is more planned and retrospective, which enables an investigation of the actions that were taken.

The Importance of Reflective Practice

Schön’s theory points out various important reasons reflective practice is crucial.

Learning from Experience: Reflective practice, according to Schön, would encourage professionals to learn from experience rather than depend on theoretical input. In real-world scenarios, this will be particularly apt for fields where situations and events are complex and quite unpredictable. Through the reflection on past experiences, professionals can garner insights that would help improve future performances.

Continuous Professional Development: Professionals, through constant reflection, can determine areas in which they need to develop further skills or knowledge. All this leads to continuous improvement and helps maintain a high level of competence in the field. Reflective models, therefore, forms no one-off activity but a sequence toward lifelong learning.

Improved problem-solving skills: Critical judgment over situations and problem-solving skills are things that can be developed by reflective practice. One can look back on how they handled a certain situation, for instance, and consider the alternative strategies and approaches to handle it—hence sharpening their skills to handle similar challenges in the future.

Adaptation to Change: The modern professional environment is fast and at times continually changing. In this type of environment, one has to adapt to whatever changes come about. Reflection on action enables the professional to be more flexible and responsive to change, since a reflective practice allows the professional to evaluate actions for necessary adjustment.

Improved Decision Making: Reflective practice sharpens up decision-making. Professionals are able to think about the outcomes that their actions will elicit. They are, therefore, in a capacity to balance between variety and have informed choice come the future.

Application of Schön’s Theory in Other Disciplines

Reflective practice can be done in any professional field since it is principle-based while generalization from one context to another can easily be made.

Education: In terms of education, teaching requires a lot of reflective models since, at all times, teachers need to check and adapt their methods to cater to the needs of their students. Example- a reflection of the effectiveness of a lesson plan done by the teacher after a class, what was good, what was bad. This reflection will help in improving the methods used in teaching and making the learning process more successful. This way, teachers are able to go on collaborative reflections where knowledge is shared and the best practices are developed among other professionals.

Healthcare: Reflective practice in healthcare maintains better care for patients. Most of the time, healthcare professionals operate in situations of difficulty and pressure which demand high-speed thinking and shift in flexibility. Through reflection, heath care workers can realize how to arrive at decisions in order to improve a patient’s situation and in communication issues. For instance, the reflection of a difficult conversation with a relative of a patient for a nurse might be used to think through how he or she might have communicated more effectively.

Social work: Social workers deal with complex social issues that require delicate intervention and support. Reflective practice helps in seeing how actions directly affect clients and further developing more effective strategies for support. In reflecting on the interaction with the client, they come to the realization of the very needs of the people they are serving and adjust accordingly in their approaches.

Management: In the area of management, reflective practice plays a critical role in effective leadership and decision-making. A better manager can reflect on the dynamics of the team and effects of his or her decision on the group, hence improving the ways of managing in retrospect. A manager may reflect on what went wrong with the project, reasons for the failure, and learning points for future.

Law: Through reflective practice, lawyers can revisit case strategies and performance in the courtroom. Reflecting on legal arguments and reactions to them can improve techniques and bring success in future cases. It helps to consider ethical implications and make more reasonable decisions.

Challenges of Reflective Practice

Although Schön’s reflective practice theory has numerous advantages, it also has its share of drawbacks:

Time constraints: Many professions take so much time that scant time is left to reflect. The practitioners don’t have enough time to reflect on their actions and the decisions taken, more so when the scenario requires them to act instantaneously.

Emotional Discomfort: It is not a tasteful job to think over the mistakes or failures of some people. It requires being honest with the self, having determination, and facing those areas that need a little improvement. Such deep self-analysis may not be an easy exercise for some professionals to undergo.

Lack of Structure: Without a structured approach, reflection can be aimless or superficial. For reflection to be effective, it needs to be systematic and purposeful. Reflectivity tools can be beneficial for encouraging professionals to engage with the process.

Over-Reflection Risk: As much as one would wish to reflect, there is also the risk of over-reflecting, which can lead to overthinking the situation, resulting in indecision or even second-guessing oneself. The professional, in this regard, is to balance thoughtful reflection by acting decisively.

Supporting Reflective Practice

There are several ways a professional can enhance reflective practice to maximize the benefits one can derive from it.

Reflective journaling: Recording the reflections of experiences gone through in a day would provide a method of organizing thoughts and over due course, pattern recognition. Reflective practice inspires deeper analysis, and, like this, one can trace progress.

Peer reflection: Sharing experiences with peers provides new perspectives and insights. Peer reflection helps to create a learning environment where everyone can share best practices.

Apply Structured Reflection Models: Tools like the Gibbs Reflective Cycle or the Kolb Learning Cycle will give a structured approach to reflection. This takes professionals through a detailed review of their experience to establish what has been learned.

Set up Regular Times to Reflect: Setting specific times to reflect, for example at the end of the day or the week, will help professionals remember to reflect regularly in their practice.

Conclusion

Reflection in practice, according to Schön’s theoretical exercise, is really one strong process of professional growth and enhancement. Continuous improvement in practice and adaptation of practice in a changing environment, coupled with enhanced decision-making abilities, are developed through reflection in action and reflection on action. Although reflective practice is challenging, its benefits make it quite an important process in life. Educational, health, and any other field; it is actually through reflective practice that one may find an avenue toward further understanding, better outcomes, and personal and professional development.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top